Is Wooden Floor More Expensive Than Carpet? Why Choose One

Wooden Vs Carpet flooring cost
what is the Wooden Vs Carpet flooring cost

Cost of wood flooring versus carpet: I have seen people ask; is carpet or hardwood cheaper? well, the debate can never see its end. As there some that believe that carpet flooring are more expensive due to the annual maintenance cost others think that hardwood floors are more expensive. Just read to the end to see what I think of the cost of installing either of the two.

Both wooden floors and carpets are important and popular types of flooring, so understanding what each comprises is necessary to be able to make an informed decision.

They are two of the most prevalent flooring materials, yet they are also the most opposite to one another.

One is a fully synthetic, soft, calm, and affordable material with a very limited lifespan, whilst the other is a natural, hard, and costly flooring material that is likely to outlast you.

However, each have important functions to perform, and you may find yourself employing both materials in various parts of your home.

Each has a unique set of qualities that make them suitable for various locations and purposes. Understanding the materials’ properties will enable you to make educated decisions about how to use them in diverse settings.

Let us take you through various comparisons: wooden vs carpet.

Carpet vs. Hardwood Flooring

The majority of contemporary carpet is made by weaving closely spaced loops of synthetic fibers through enormous sheets of backing material.

There are some natural-fiber carpets, primarily made of cotton or wool, but the great majority are made of synthetic materials ranging from nylon to polyester. Carpet is made in big rolls, and customers buy it by the foot in whatever amounts they want.

Modern hardwood flooring often comes in two varieties. As the name implies, solid hardwood flooring is made from planks of solid wood cut from fallen hardwood trees.

The top surface of these boards is sanded smooth, but the bottom is left slightly rough. The boards’ edges are fashioned with tongue-and-groove joints that allow them to interlock when they are placed.

Engineered hardwood flooring is another type of hardwood flooring. These boards are made by bonding a thin surface layer of genuine hardwood to a thicker (and less expensive) core layer of high-quality plywood.

This structure not only reduces the cost of the flooring, but it also offers the boards hardwood stability against expanding and contracting owing to changes in humidity levels.

Most types of engineered wood flooring have the same tongue-and-groove construction as solid hardwood flooring and are placed in the same manner.

List Of The Types Of Wooden Floors

It is significant to remember that a variety of woods, including oak, maple, cherry, etc., can be utilized to create either of these wooden floors.

For the types of wooden floors, we have

  • Unfinished, sturdy planks
  • Authentic Prefinished Planks
  • Designed Planks
  • Recycled Wood Planks

Types Of Carpet

For the types of carpets we have:

  • Wool carpeting 
  • Nylon Carpeting
  • Polyester Carpeting
  • Carpet made of leather
  • Carpeting made of acrylic
  • Carpet Material Made of Polypropylene

Wooden Floor Vs Carpets: Which Is Better?

The importance of each is equal. Some people favor carpet over wood and vice versa.

On the other hand, those who have carpet will undoubtedly like it and vote for it as the greatest, while those who have wooden floors will say the same about them. Because of its sturdiness and aesthetic appeal, wood is recommended for use as a home’s primary flooring. Carpets can be used as the flooring of an office.

Wooden Floor Vs Carpet: Which Is More Expensive?

The price gap is not that much nevertheless a carpet cost around $6.25 to $25 per square foot and it also includes removal. While a wood floor cost around  $6 to $22 per square foot.

A lot of things can affect the cost of wooden floors and carpets, such as the brand of wood and carpet, quality of the carpet and wood, and lifespan- how long can each of them last.

Here are breakdown of the cost of different carpet and wood materials that will generally contribute to the cost of the final product.

Carpet Material Options

Fiber TypeCost per Square FootDescription
NYLON$1.00 – $6.50Most commonDurableNot typically stain-resistantUse in: general home
WOOL$4.50 – $10.00Natural fiberDurableStain-resistantEasy to cleanUse in: medium-traffic areas
OLEFIN$1.50 – $2.25Durable.Moisture-resistant.Stain-resistant.Sensitive to high heat.Use in: basement, exterior, low-traffic areas
POLYESTER$0.25 – $4.50Stain-resistantLess variety to design and color optionsUse in: low-traffic areas, bedrooms

Carpet Style Options

PileCost per Square FootDescription
CUT PILE PLUSH$3.50 – $4.50Soft and smoothShows imprints and dirt easilyUse in: formal rooms
CUT PILE SAXONY$2.00 – $7.00Twisted pileSmoothHides imprints easilyUse in: medium-traffic areas
CUT PILE TEXTURED$0.75 – $2.00SoftResists soilingTwo-tonedUse in: general home
CUT PILE FRIEZE$1.00 – $4.00Twisted pileHides imprints easilyUse in: high-traffic areas
CUT AND LOOP$1.00 – $6.00Incorporates both cut and loop pileHides dirtUse in: high-traffic areas
MULTI-LEVEL LOOP$1.30 – $4.00Hides dirtPet paws could get caught in loopsUse in: high-traffic areas
LEVEL LOOP$1.50 – $8.50Berber is a type of level loopPet paws could get caught in loopsUse in: high-traffic areas
carpeting vs hardwood floors cost

Wood Floors

These options range greatly in hardness, grain, color and price.

SpeciesCost per Square FootDescription
MAPLE$3.50 – $6.00One of the most common optionsVery hardResists stains
OAK$4.50 – $7.00One of the most common optionsVery durableDark grain
PINE$3.50 – $7.00One of the most common optionsConsidered a softwood
ASH$5.00 – $9.00Very hardLight-colored
CORK$3.00 – $8.00Environmentally-friendlyDurableCushioned feelNot moisture-resistant
BAMBOO$2.00 – $4.00Not a true hardwood, but it is just as hardMoisture-resistantSustainable
HICKORY$3.00 – $6.00Very hardDurable
BRAZILIAN CHERRY$4.00 – $9.00Also known as JatobaVery hardBurgundy
BRAZILIAN WALNUT$5.00 – $9.00Also known as IpeDurableVery hardDark-colored

Cost Comparison


Carpet as a material costs as little as $1 – $2 per square foot and as much as $9 – $11 per square foot. For an average 12’ by 12’ space, you could pay $150 to $1,500 for the material alone.


Hardwood as a material costs as little as $3 – $6 per square foot and as much as $8 – $14 per square foot. For an average 12’ by 12’ space, you could pay $450 to $2,000 for hardwood alone

Wooden Floor Vs Carpets: What Are The Differences?

wooden vs carpet flooring
wooden vs carpet flooring

Here is a detailed description of the differences between wooden floors and carpets:

Cost VariationThe quality of the wood may have an impact on the price. The price per square foot for a wood floor ranged from $6 to $22.The quality of the carpet may affect the price. Costs for carpet range from $6.25 to $25 per square foot.
Maintenance More easily maintained than carpet is wooden floors. Therefore, it is obvious that when it comes to upkeep, wood floors outperform carpeted flooring.
Wood floors can last up to 25 years with proper maintenance. Using only a broom and mop you are good to go
Many carpet floors come with a recommended method of cleaning from where they were purchased, and some carpet floors have specialized cleaning modes and patterns.
Installation Installing a carpet is less expensive than installing a wooden floor. Depending on the type of wood, color, wood grain, and quality, hardwood flooring typically costs between $6 and $12 per square foot.
This indicates that the materials to install a wooden floor in a 144-square-foot room would cost between $864 and $1,728. The price per square foot for hiring a professional to install the wooden floor varies between $3 and $5.
A carpet’s installation costs are lower. A 144-square-foot room would cost between $288 and $1,008 to carpet on average, as carpet costs between $2 and $7 per square foot.
If you want to hire a professional, budget between $788 and $2,797.
Health Ground Because pet hair, dust, and other allergens are far easier to clean up than carpet, wood flooring is unquestionably the best option for families with allergy sufferers.Carpet flooring is not the ideal option for your home if allergies are a concern for anyone in it. The wood floor is the greatest option.
This is because of the intricate design of the carpet, which can make it very challenging to thoroughly eliminate any allergens that have been trapped in the millions of densely woven threads that trigger these allergies, including dust, grime, pet hair, dander, and others.
While routine vacuuming can help keep the carpet clean, allergens can still get embedded so deeply in the carpet fibers that deep cleaning of the floor is required to get rid of them entirely.
Safety and Sound AbsorptionThere is hardly much sound absorption. On a wood floor, you can hear footsteps.Carpeted floors absorb sound better than other surfaces do.
Longevity and RobustnessIf properly laid, wood flooring is a very durable option that lasts much longer than carpet.Although a carpet’s durability and longevity are shorter than those of a wooden floor, with proper care, it can survive for a very long period.
Differences between carpets and wooden floors

Wooden Floor Vs Carpets: What Are The Advantages?

Before making a decision about which flooring you want to go for, take a look at the advantages of wooden floors and carpets. Wooden vs carpet: advantages:

  • Both Have Numerous Installation Techniques: There are numerous installation techniques for both carpet and wooden floors. They can also be put in as a do-it-yourself job.
  • Both Are Eco-Friendly: If you care about preserving a healthy environment and preserving your health, you should choose an eco-friendly flooring material. Carpet and wooden floors are the greatest options because they are not damaging to the environment. Eco-friendly carpets and wood floors are also available because they lack harmful chemicals in their construction. They are therefore appropriate and secure for use in homes with kids and pets.
  • Both Are Available in a Variety of Styles: Both carpet and wooden floors come in a variety of styles and come in a wide range of colors, textures, and sizes. So, you can make a decision based on your needs and preferences.
  • Both Are Water and Heat Resistant: Water and heat resistance varies greatly depending on the kind of flooring, although carpet and wooden floors are completely resistant to both.

Frequently Asked Questions About Carpeting vs Hardwood Floors cost

Is It A Good Idea To Replace Carpet With Wood Flooring?

Due to their resilience, extended lifespan, and attractive appearance, wooden floors are a good option if you are no longer in need of using carpet.

How Can  A Wooden Floor Be Cleaned To Maintain Its Durability And Longevity?

Regular sweeping or vacuuming will keep a wooden floor looking wonderful. This will assist in removing dust and other material that could result in scratches. Additionally, you should clear up spills right away and wash damp floors using cleaners made specifically for wooden floors. Throwing rugs in the entryway to rooms with wooden flooring is another excellent option.

Which Wood Type Is Best for a Wooden Floor?

It totally depends on your preferences and what you want. But since it is something you want to utilize for your residences, you can also seek the assistance of an expert to prevent errors.

How Much Does A Wooden Floor Cost?

The price of a wooden floor ranged from $6 to $22 per square foot.

Is It Recommended to Replace a Wooden Floor With Carpet?

It is absolutely up to the user if that is what they wish to do. A carpet typically lasts for 10 to 15 years. Therefore, you should replace the carpet after 15 years of use.

How Should Carpet Be Cleaned To Preserve Durability?

Every carpet is cleaned uniquely and in accordance with suggestions. Therefore, it is wise to clean carpets according to the manufacturers’ instructions to lengthen their lifespan.

Which Kind Of Carpet Is Best To Use?

The user is the only one who can decide. We have carpets made of wool, polyester, nylon, and olefin (polypropylene). All of these carpet varieties now come in a variety of price ranges. They range in price from $7.50 to $5.50 per square foot; the average price for similar properties is between $2 and $4 per square foot.

How Much Does A Carpet Cost

For an area up to 200 square feet, carpet installation typically costs $700 to $2,000, while carpet material expenses average $2.50 per square foot or $10 per yard. Padding beneath the mattress costs roughly $0.60 per square foot.


In my expert advice, I will say hardwood flooring is more expensive and durable than carpet flooring because Carpet installation costs homeowners an average of $1,600, with the majority spending between $700 and $2,500. Labor costs between $0.50 and $1.00 per square foot, with extra services such as furniture removal and specialty cutting costing between $0.50 and $2.00 per square foot.

Installation is frequently simpler than with hardwood. The key pricing determinants are the fibers, pile type, and square footage involved.

while, the average cost of hardwood flooring installation is $4,400, with a usual range of $2,500 to $6,500. Labor accounts for between $3 and $8 per square foot of the total cost. This flooring requires more detailed installation, and the cost will vary based on the species and the quantity of floor space required.


You May Also Like