Broiling and grilling are two food preparation methods that are similar but have some differences between them. These two cooking methods are usually for preparing beef and chicken.
Grilling and broiling both used intense heat to cook. The main difference between these two cooking methods is the source of heat. While grilling uses a direct source of heat below the food, broiling involves using a direct heat source above the food.
But what type of food should you broil or grill?
Keep reading to find out the similarities and differences between broiling vs grilling.
What Is Broiling?
Broiling is a method of food preparation which involves cooking by direct radiant heat. It’s a cooking method of roasting food using a direct source of heat above the food.
Broiling cooks your food at a higher temperature of over 550 degrees Fahrenheit or 287 degrees Celsius. However, the ideal temperature to broil your food in an oven is between 320 to 400 degrees Fahrenheit or 160 to 204 degrees Celsius.
The broiler pan or baking sheet is where the food id placed and it collects the fats released by the food as it broils.
The broiler section of the oven is either at the top rack or in a separate compartment below the oven. The heating element of the broiler is located directly on top of the food.
Broiling caramelizes foods, giving it a brown colour and a unique flavour.
Also Read: Essential Oils vs Carrier Oils: Differences and Comparison
What Type of Food is Good for Broiling?
Broiling is a cooking method of roasting food using a direct source of heat above the food. Beef and chicken are usually the type of food best for broiling. But besides beef and chicken, there are other foods you can broil.
You can broil meat like ribeye, top loin, tender beef cuts, steaks, porterhouse, T-bone, flank, top sirloin, tri-tip sirloin, and tenderloin.
For chicken, you should broil boneless breast halves, legs, chicken quarters, chicken halves, and bone-in breasts.
Turkey breast cutlets and tenderloin steaks are parts you should broil.
Fruits like bananas, peaches, pineapple plums, grapefruits, mangoes, and nectarines are best for broiling. Some vegetables that are good for broiling include tomato halves, onion wedges, asparagus spears, and bell pepper strips.
Also, you can broil shrimp, skewers, pork, and shrimp.
What Is Grilling?
Grilling is a cooking method that we are all familiar with. It’s a method of food preparation that involves heating food on top of a metal grate placed directly over a fire.
Unlike broiling, the source of heat in grilling is located below the food. Grilling your meat, fish or chicken is done on a stand-alone grill. A grill may run on propane or natural gas, as well as charcoal or firewood.
The grilling process can heat foods to a high temperature of 600 degrees Fahrenheit or 315 degrees Celsius. However, the ideal temperature for grilling is usually between 350 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit or 176 to 232 degrees Celsius.
You can grill your foods with an electric grill, gas or propane grill, charcoal grill, pellet grill, or charcoal kettle grill.
Grilling gives your food a dark searing colour on the outside, with delicious grilling marks.
What Type of Food is Good for Grilling?
You can grill beef, chicken, fish, burger patties, fruits, and vegetables.
Lamb chops, pork loins, ribs, steak, flank steak, pork chops, and pork tenderloin are best for grilling.
Chicken breast, chicken satay, salmon, tilapia, branzino, fish tacos, chipotle, shrimp, and shrimp tacos are food you should grill.
Fruits and vegetables that you can also grill include watermelon, peaches, tomatoes, eggplants, potatoes, asparagus, romaine lettuce, cauliflower, green beans, mushrooms, zucchini, and artichokes.
Also Read: TSP vs TBSP: Difference and Comparison
Broiling vs Grilling: Key Differences between Broiling and Grilling
| Broiling | Grilling | |
| Source of heat | The direct source of heat is located above the food | The direct source of heat is located below the food |
| Smoke | Broiling foods do not produce smoke but if it does, then it’s not normal. | Grilling foods usually produces lots of smoke and it’s very normal. |
| Temperature control | When broiling, you cannot control the temperature | But when grilling, you have complete control of the grill’s temperature |
| Outdoor/indoor use | Broiling can be done indoors in an oven with a broiling setting | Grilling is meant for outdoor cooking because of the smoke produced |
Broiling vs Grilling: More Key Differences between Broiling and Grilling
Let’s some of the key differences between broiling and grilling.
The Kitchen Equipment
Broiling and grilling are two methods of cooking that use direct radiant heat to make a charred-flavoured meal.
Broiling is done indoors and it relies on a gas-powered or electric oven. The broiler section of the oven is either at the top rack or in a separate compartment below the oven.
Grilling on the other hand is an outdoor cooking method that normally produces smoke. It’s unwise and unsafe to bring an outdoor grill inside the house.
Outdoor grills are not designed for indoor cooking. Only an indoor-approved electric grill should be used inside the house.
The Heat Source
Broiling and grilling are two cooking methods that are similar but have a difference in their heat source. Broiling is done indoors by using an electric or gas-powered oven.
The grilling process involves cooking food over an open flame heating the food from below.
The source of heat in grilling is located below the food. A grill may run on propane or natural gas, as well as charcoal or firewood.
Flavour
Grilling and broiling are cooking methods that use dry heat to caramelize food. The grilling process infuses a heavier charred flavour, whereas broiling makes a lightly charred flavour.
People who prefer smoky, burnt-flavoured foods may choose grilled foods over broiled ones.
Also Read: Volume vs Capacity: Difference and Comparison
Broiling vs Grilling: Similarities between Broiling and Grilling
Broiling and Grilling share a few similarities we will be looking into.
Smoke Created
Both broiling and grilling are cooking methods, especially for cooking beef and chicken. Since these two cooking methods are used to cook meat, meat with fat can cause smoke.
Broiling is an indoor cooking method that does not produce any smoke. But if there is smoke when you are broiling, it’s an indication of a fault. Grilling is an outdoor cooking method and the presence of smoke is normal.
Flare-ups Can Occur
In both grilling and broiling, flames can emerge from the grease so it’s important to check your food while broiling or grilling.
Keep a baking soda close when you are grilling or broiling because it can stop small flames.
Also Read: Olive Oil vs Butter: Difference and Comparison
Preheating
These two cooking methods require preheating before the food is placed inside. It’s the normal process if you want to cook a delicious meal by broiling or grilling.
Preheating your oven or grill will make your chicken, beef, or fish cook at a consistent temperature. It gives your meal a heavier or lightly charred flavour.
If you are using gas grills and ovens, you should preheat it for about ten minutes before putting your food on the grate or pan. It may take a longer period to preheat charcoal grills but once the coals are white or grey colour, it’s ready for the grilling process.
Conclusion
Grilling and broiling both used intense heat to cook. While grilling uses a direct source of heat below the food, broiling involves using a direct heat source above the food.
Both grilling and broiling are cooking methods that use dry heat to caramelize food but the grilling process infuses a heavier charred flavour, whereas broiling makes a lightly charred flavour.
Recommendations
- Cooking vs Baking: Difference and Comparison
- Baking vs Roasting: Difference and Comparison
- Hypothesis vs Prediction: Differences and Comparison
- Dissertation vs Thesis: Difference and Comparison
- Odds vs Probability: Difference and Comparison
References
- Masterclass: Broiling vs. Grilling: How Do They Compare?
- Sodelicious.recipe: Grilling Versus Broiling. Why It’s Important to Know the Differences
- Buythermopro: Differences Between Grilling and Broiling
- Atgrillscookware: DIFFERENCES BETWEEN BROILING AND GRILLING
- Tastylicious: Grilling vs Broiling: Differences and Similarities
